alexander d schwartz - suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
1/25
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
2/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 1
Part I: Exposure Matrix
Exposure Analysis for SUN Area Technical Institute
Loss Exposure Provided Coverage/Benefits Provided
Loss of Income: Medical ExpensesOverall Medical Expenses Yes Capital BlueCross: Traditional Indemnity,
Preferred Provider PPOGeisinger: In-Network HMOKeystone Health Plan-Cen.: In-Network HMO
Dental Yes Capital BlueCross Dental
Vision Yes NCAS Vision
Prescription Yes Capital BlueCross: Traditional Indemnity,Preferred Provider PPO
Geisinger: In-Network HMOKeystone Health Plan-Cen.: In-Network HMO
Retiree Health Care Yes MedicareCOBRA
Loss of Income: Death
Non-Accidental & Non-Occupational Yes Group Term LifeOASDI
Accidental Yes Group Term LifeAccidental Death & DismembermentOASDI
Occupational Yes Group Term LifeAccidental Death & DismembermentWorkers CompensationOASDI
Loss of Income: Unemployment
Unemployment Yes Unemployment Insurance
Loss of Income: Disability
Non-Occupational: Short-Term Yes PTO (Sick Leave)Accidental Death & Dismemberment
Non-Occupational: Long-Term Yes Accidental Death & DismembermentOASDI
Occupational: Short-Term Yes Accidental Death & DismembermentWorkers CompensationOASDI
Occupational: Long-Term Yes Accidental Death & DismembermentWorkers CompensationOASDI
Loss of Income: Retirement
Retirement Yes Defined Benefit PlanOASDI
Other Exposures
Work / Life Yes Employee Wellness Program
Educational Assistance No
Dependent Care No
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
3/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 2
Part II: Inventory of Benefits
MEDICAL EXPENSES:
Definitions and Eligibility Conditions:
SUN Area Technical Institute offers a variety of healthcare benefits to its employees.
Employees have the option of four different health insurance plans, each of which includes a
prescription drug insurance plan. Additionally, employees are offered a dental and vision plan.
All of the plans previously mentioned have the same definitions and eligibility conditions.
All full time employees that are legal residents of the United States are eligible for coverage
from the first day they start work. An employee is considered full time if they work a minimum
of 30 hours during a regularly scheduled work week. A full time employees dependents are also
eligible for coverage from the first day the employee starts work. Eligible dependants are defined
as an employees spouse and an employees dependent child. If a divorce is finalized, then a
spouse is no longer considered a dependent. An eligible dependent child is defined as: (1)
unmarried children up to age 19, including step children and legally adopted children; (2)
unmarried children up to age 26 if they are enrolled and attending a college, university, technical,
or specialized school full time. Each individual plans aspects are as follows:
Traditional Indemnity Plan:
SUN Area Technical Institute offers a fully insured Traditional Indemnity Plan, which is
administered by Capital BlueCross. Since Capital BlueCross is a not-for-profit organization there
is currently no rating by any rating agency. This plan is offered to all full time employees and
their dependents, as defined under the Definitions and Eligibility section. This plan is offered on
a non-contributory basis. The cost sharing arrangements and services provided under this plan
are as follows:
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
4/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 3
Basic (Hospital / Surgical / Medical)
Covered Person(s) Deductible
(Initial Deductible)
Out-of-Pocket Maximum
1 Person None None
Family None None
SUNs Traditional benefit plan covers a wide array of procedures. All Inpatient and Outpatient
Hospital Services are covered for 100% of UCR. Preventive Care services, such as child and
adult physical exams are not covered, but all other preventative procedures are covered for 80%
of UCR.
Additionally, SUN employees have access to a Supplemental Major Medical plan, to fill
coverage gaps and enhance the benefits offered through their Basic Plan. This plan has a
$500,000 lifetime maximum. The cost sharing arrangements and services provided under this
plan are as follows:
Major Medical (Supplemental)
Covered Person(s) Deductible
(Corridor Deductible)
Out-of-Pocket Maximum
1 Person $50 $400
Family $100 $400 per life insured
The supplemental major medical plan will cover any expenses that are not within the scope of
the basic plan. One example of this from SUNs plan would be the rental or purchase of home
medical equipment. This service is excluded from the basic plan, but is covered for 80% of UCR
under the Major Medical plan. The Major Medical plan will also cover any expenses that are not
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
5/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 4
covered under the Basic plan due to the plans benefits being exhausted, or due to a dollar limit
being reached.
Preferred Provider Organization (PPO):
Another option offered by SUN Area Technical Institute is a fully insured PPO plan
administered by Capital BlueCross. Since Capital BlueCross is a not-for-profit organization it is
not issued a rating by any rating agency. This plan is again offered to all full time employees and
their dependants, as defined under the Definitions and Eligibility section. This plan is also
offered on a non-contributory basis. The cost sharing arrangements and services in this plan are
as follows:
PPO
Covered
Persons
Deductible
(In-Network)
Deductible
(Out-of-Network)
Out of Pocket Max
(In-Network)
Out of Pocket Max
(Out-of-Network)
Individual None $500 None $3,000
Family None $1,000 None $6,000
This PPO plan has a $20 co-pay for routine physical examinations, office visits for in-network
providers, and pays for 70% of UCR for out-of-network providers. For inpatient and outpatient
hospital services this plan pays 100% of UCR for in-network providers and 70% of UCR for out-
of-network providers.
Health Maintenance Organization (HMO):
Geisinger Health Plan
SUN Area Technical Institute also offers a fully insured HMO plan administered by
Geisinger Health Plan. Geisinger Health plan is not rated by any rating agency because it is also
a not-for-profit organization. This plan is an in-network only HMO meaning that no coverage
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
6/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 5
is provided for out-of-network utilization of healthcare goods and services. A list of available in-
network providers is posted online by Geisinger Health. This plan is again offered to all full time
employees and their dependants, as defined under the Definitions and Eligibility section, and
offered on a non-contributory basis. The cost sharing arrangements and services under this plan
are as follows:
Geisinger Health Plan
Covered Persons Deductible
(In-Network Only)
Out of Pocket Max
(In-Network Only)
Individual None None
Family None None
The Geisinger Health Plan has a $20 copayment per office visit with a primary care physician,
and a $35 copayment per office visit to a specialist with a referral. This plan pays 100% of UCR
for both inpatient and outpatient hospital services.
Keystone Health Plan-Central
SUN Area Technical Institute offers a fully insured HMO plan that is administered by
Keystone Health Plan-Central, a subsidiary of Capital BlueCross. This plan is an in-network
only HMO, so no coverage is provided for healthcare goods and services utilized outside the
provider network. A list of available in-network providers is posted online by Keystone Health
Plan-Central. Since Keystone Health Plan-Central is a subsidiary of Capital BlueCross it is also a
not-for-profit organization, meaning there is no rating from any rating agency. This plan is again
offered to all full time employees and their dependants, as defined under the Definitions and
Eligibility section. This plan, like all the others, is offered on a non-contributory basis. The cost
sharing arrangements and services under this plan are as follows:
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
7/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 6
Keystone Health Plan-Central
Covered Person(s) Deductible
(In Network Only)
Out-of-Pocket Maximum
(In Network Only)
1 Person None NoneFamily None None
All Inpatient Hospital Services are covered in full with no dollar or day limit. All Outpatient
Services are covered in full, regardless of cost. Most preventive care services (such as physical
exams, routine screenings, and mammograms) are covered with a $25 copayment. Similarly,
physician services (such as office visits, and maternity newborn care) are covered with a $25
copayment.
Prescription Drug Coverage:
With SUNs benefit plan, each health insurance plan contains its own prescription drug
coverage. Each prescription drug policy is administered by the same organization that
administered the health plan, and any employee participating in the health plan is eligible for the
corresponding prescription drug coverage. Just like each healthcare plan, these plans are offered
to all full time employees and their dependents, as defined under the Definitions and Eligibility
section. These plans are all offered on a non-contributory basis. Each plan has its own specific
cost sharing arrangements and limits, which are as follows:
1) Traditional Indemnity Plan:
Since this is an Indemnity Plan, there are no in-network or out-of-network pharmacies,
but merely different cost sharing arrangements for generic and brand name prescription drugs.
The plan uses a percent coinsurance method to determine cost sharing by employees. For generic
drugs the plan will cover 100% of the cost. Where, for brand name drugs the plan will cover 80%
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
8/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 7
of the cost. Employees also have the option to use a mail order program where they can receive
their prescriptions through the mail after the first 32 days of supply. With this option generic
drugs have a 15% copayment, up to a maximum of $15. While brand name drugs have a 20%
copayment, up to a maximum of $20.
2) Preferred PPO Plan:
This plan uses percent coinsurance based on a discounted amount, and there is an initial
deductable of $50 per person per calendar year. Just like the health plan, this prescription drug
option has both in-network and out-of-network pharmacies. Through this plan generic drugs that
are purchased in-network have a copayment of 20%, up to a maximum of $25; Brand name
drugs have a copayment of 25%, up to a maximum of $50; Lastly, Multi-source drugs (brand
name drugs that have a generic equivalent, but the employee still chooses the brand name) have a
copayment of 30%, up to a maximum of $50. If drugs are purchased out-of-network then the
same limits apply, but the dispensing fee will be added to the employees contribution. Like the
Indemnity plan, the PPO plan has a mail order option for any supply past the first 32 days, up to
90 days, which has the same copayments as previously listed.
3) Geisinger Health Plan:
Geisingers prescription drug plan uses a tiered copayment system. The first tier consists
of generic drugs which have a fixed copayment of $15. The second tier consists of brand named
drugs that are listed on the formulary, which have a fixed copayment of $25. Lastly, the third tier
consists of both Multi-source drugs and brand named drugs that are notlisted on the formulary,
which have a fixed copayment of $50. Like the other prescription drug plans, Geisingers plan
does offer a mail order option for any supply over 90 days, which has double the corresponding
copayments.
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
9/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 8
4) Keystone Health Plan-Central:
Like Geisinger,KHPCs prescription drug plan uses a tiered copayment system. The first
tier consists of generic drugs which have a fixed copayment of $10. The second tier consists of
brand name drugs with no generic equivalent which have a fixed copayment of $25. Lastly, the
third tier consists of Multi-source drugs which have a fixed copayment of $40. Like the other
prescription drug plans, KHPC does offer a mail order option for any supply past the first 30
days, up to 90 days, which has double the corresponding copayments.
Dental
SUN Area Technical Institute offers a dental plan administered by Capital BlueCross
Dental. Capital BlueCross is a not-for-profit organization so it is not rated by any rating agency.
This plan is offered on a non-contributory basis. The dental plan is offered to all full time
employees and their dependents, as defined under the Definitions and Eligibility section.
Participants in this plan must have one dental checkup per calendar year. If any
recommendations of services are made by the dentist during that visit, the plan participants must
receive those services during the same calendar year as their initial appointment. Dental charges
paid by the plan are based on years of employment as follows: Year 1 of employment 70% UCR;
Year 2 of employment 80% UCR; Year 3 of employment 90% UCR; after Year 3 100% UCR. If
a plan participant fails to have a dental checkup or follow up on recommended services in any
calendar year, payments of future claims reset to Year 1 of employment with 70% UCR. This
plan also carries a $50 lifetime per person deductible, and a $500 yearly maximum.
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
10/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 9
Vision
SUN Area Technical institute also offers a vision plan administered by NCAS, a subsidiary of
Capital BlueCross. Since NCAS is a subsidiary of Capital BlueCross it is not rated by any rating
agency due to the fact that it is a not-for-profit organization. The vision plan is offered to all full
time employees and their dependents, as defined under the Definitions and Eligibility section.
This plan is also offered on a non-contributory basis. The plan pays 100% of UCR for eye
examinations and refractive services. Refractive services would include: case history, visual
acuity (near and far), external examination, distance and near examinations, and
ophthalmoscopic examinations. The plan also partially covers post-refractive services. Post-
refractive services would include: ordering lenses and frames, adjustment of completed glasses
to a patients face, cost of materials, and verifying completed prescription upon return from the
lab.
LOSS OF INCOME: DEATH
Life Insurance and AD&D
SUN Area Technical Institute offers a fully insured non-contributory group life insurance
policy to their employees. This plan is administered through Reliance Standard Life Insurance
Company who was issued a rating of A by AM Best rating agency (www.ambest.com). This
plan includes Group Life Insurance and Accidental Death and Dismemberment Insurance
(AD&D). Eligible participants in this plan include all full-time employees who are legal United
States citizens, except any person(s) employed on a temporary or seasonal basis. The term full-
time is defined under this plan as working a minimum of 30 hours during a regularly scheduled
work week. A full time employee becomes eligible for this plan on the day their employment
begins. The amount of life insurance that is given to plan participants is one and one half times
http://www.ambest.com/http://www.ambest.com/http://www.ambest.com/http://www.ambest.com/ -
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
11/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 10
their earnings, rounded to the next higher $1,000, and subject to a maximum amount of
$150,000. The amount payable under the AD&D plan is the same as the life insurance policy,
with the same maximum of $150,000. Once a plan participant reaches age 65, the amount that
the life and AD&D policy will pay out reduces as follows:
Plan Participant Age Percentage Amount that Plan Payment
Reduces
65 35%
70 65%
75 75%
80 85%
LOSS OF INCOME: RETIREMENT
Pension Plan:
SUN Area Technical Institute offers a pension plan for all fulltime employees that is self
funded and offered on a non-contributory basis. The term full-time is defined under this plan
as working a minimum of 30 hours during a regularly scheduled work week. In order to be
eligible to participate, employees must be at least 21 years of age, and must have worked at SUN
for at least one year. Years of service are used to determine an employees pension amount. This
amount is determined by taking the employees average salary overthe last five years of
employment and dividing by 12 months. Employees begin receiving their benefit at age 65, and
will continue to receive the benefit until their death. Employees will receive pension benefits if
they retire early, but the amount will be reduced based on the number of years. If an employee
dies while still employed, his/her dependants will receive the pension amount in one lump sum
payment.
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
12/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 11
OTHER EXPOSURES
Work / Life:
Additionally, SUN Area Technical Institute offers its employees an Employee Wellness
Program. This program is offered on a non-contributory basis, is self-funded, and is administered
by Capital BlueCross. This program is offered to all full time employees and their dependents, as
defined under the Definitions and Eligibility section under Medical Expenses. The Employee
Wellness Program provides services for employees and dependents for such issues as: personal
health, marriage, family, emotional well-being, stress, and other personal issues at no cost to the
employee. All of these Work / Life services can be accessed on Capital BlueCross website, or
by calling a toll free number. This benefit, like any Work / Life benefit, is designed to hopefully
keep employees healthy and happy, which results in higher efficiency and productivity for the
employer.
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
13/25
Benefits Analysis
Part III
RMI 3501
912-55-1427
912-43-4791
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
14/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 1
Introduction
SUN Area Technical Institute (SUN) is a vocational technical school located in New
Berlin, Pennsylvania, and serves over 300 students from four different school districts within the
area. SUN offers a variety of programs of study including: automotive technology, computer
aided drafting and design, cosmetology, criminal justice, culinary arts, dental health services,
electronics technology, and many others. SUN is a public state school, so it is funded by
Pennsylvania state taxes. What differentiates SUN from the typical vocational technical school is
that they also offer classes for adults to receive certifications in some of the offered programs.
The overall goal of SUN is to provide area students with skills needed to compete in todays job
market, and receive consideration for college placement.
SUN Area Technical Institute currently employs 55 employees and covers 181 lives
under its employee benefits package. This analysis examines the benefits that are currently
offered to employees by the organization. Throughout this project our contact person has been
James King, SUN Area Technical Institutes business administrator for the past ten years. He
maintains the sole responsibility of determining the types and levels of benefits that are offered
to SUNs employees. However, the final decision of whether the plan will be implemented lies
with the Joint Operating Committee, which is essentially SUNs version of an administrative
school board.
Employee Benefits Plan Objectives
After interviewing Mr. King, it is clear that one of the main goals of SUNs employee
benefit plan is to offer superior healthcare benefits. When employees are dealing with their
benefits, most people tend to focus on healthcare. So when designing its employee benefit
package, SUN decided to give people what they were looking for by offering four different
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
15/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 2
health insurance plans to choose from. This includes a traditional indemnity plan, a preferred
PPO plan, and two in-network HMOs.
As with most organizations, one of SUNs main objectives is to offer benefits that will
attract and retain capable employees. Mr. King believes that SUNs healthcare options
effectively do just that. By offering so many health insurance options, SUN differentiates itself
from many of the other education institutions in the area. Mr. King went on to say that the
benefit plan is not merely about beating the competition, but in his opinion SUNs healthcare
benefits are far and above what I have seen from most other employers. With four different
healthcare plans to choose from, an employee can find a plan that best fits his/her individual
needs, instead of having little to no choice in the decision. SUNs traditional indemnity plan also
helps in retaining older employees. Indemnity plans used to be the most common health
insurance plan used by employer-employee groups, but now they are extremely rare to find. The
traditional indemnity plan is an excellent option for SUNs older generation employees, because
they have become used to these plans, and are less willing to make changes. On the other hand,
the younger generation of SUN employees has the ability to choose whatever option best fits
their needs, both financially and medically.
SUN also took employee input into great consideration when designing their current
employee benefit package. Employees are encouraged to complete surveys, suggestion sheets,
and even present their case to administration. Also, at the end of the year during their teacher
evaluation, all employees sit down with the administration to discuss any problems or
suggestions they have for the employee benefit plan. As stated by Mr. King, the benefit
planning process is very much a joint effort between administration, the Joint Operating
Committee, and the employees. This joint effort clearly shows through the benefits that are
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
16/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 3
currently offered. Mr. King explained how SUNs lowest priced plan, the Geisinger in-network
HMO, was brought about by single employees who suggested that a lower priced, less
comprehensive plan should be offered for employees without families. Additionally, employee
suggestions for programs to help keep themselves and their dependents physically and
emotionally healthy led to the creation of the Employee Wellness Program, administered by
Capital BlueCross.
Another objective of SUNs benefit plan is to increase the overall efficiency,
productivity, and motivation of its employees. The organization does this by offering many
different plan options; much more than many other area school districts. Furthermore, all of these
services are offered at no additional cost to the employees, with every plan being offered on a
non-contributory basis. As Mr. King said, SUNs goal is to maximize employee satisfaction in
regards to the benefits that are offered to them, and this will result in employees that return the
favor in terms of efficiency, productivity, and company morale.
The last objective, which SUN believes is one of the most important, is very simple;
genuinely caring about its employees well-being. With only fifty-five employees, every
employee at SUN knows each others name, and the goal according to Mr. King is to form
relationships that will last beyond normal working hours. The Employee Wellness Program
offered by SUN helps achieve this. By providing personal well-being services for employees
who experience personal problems outside of work, employees are able to receive help, which
will prevent personal issues from affecting co-workers and the overall work environment. Mr.
King said with confidence that if employees genuinely enjoy coming to work every day, it
creates a better working environment for everyone.
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
17/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 4
Problems, Issues, Concerns, and Considerations
Rising Healthcare Costs
One of the biggest concerns of SUN Area Technical Institute, as well as most other
organizations, is the continuing rise of healthcare costs. When designing the structure of its
health insurance plans, SUN decided to offer a wide variety of options to make the overall
benefit package more appealing to potential employees. However, with todays healthcare costs
continuing to rise, SUNs administration has realized that offering a choice of four different
healthcare plans is creating too large of a financial burden on the school. For the coming year,
SUN has been notified that it will have an 8% premium increase for its Traditional Indemnity
Plan; a 5% premium increase for its Preferred PPO; a 12% premium increase for its Keystone
Health Plan-Central HMO; and finally a 5% premium increase for its Geisinger HMO. In Mr.
Kings words, these increases in costs are a huge concern, because not offering health insurance
benefits is simply not an option. Especially when you have prided yourself as much as we do
here at SUN with the options offered in the past.
In order to contain the problem of rising healthcare costs, SUN has decided that after this
coming year it will no longer offer its Keystone Health Plan-Central HMO. Being the more
expensive of the two in-network only HMO options, the Keystone Health Plan-Central HMO has
had an increase in its premium every year due to low enrollment and a high claims history. Mr.
King noted that this plan currently only serves a small number of employees, and it is not worth
the premium increases anymore. SUN has decided to only use the Geisinger in-network HMO in
the future. Since its inception, the plan has gained much popularity with SUN employees because
of its low copayments. Furthermore, Geisinger has yet to increase its premium more than 5% in
any one year, which is a huge plus for SUNs administration.
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
18/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 5
Funding Considerations
SUN currently funds all of the benefits offered in its benefit package through the use of
various insurance carriers. However, with healthcare costs (and in turn healthcare premiums)
constantly on the rise, SUN is considering making one of its healthcare plans self insured and
purchasing Stop-Loss insurance. Through our interview, Mr. King explains how the Geisinger
in-network HMO is currently the lowest priced plan offered to employees. He went on to say that
in order to cut costs further, SUN is in discussion with Geisinger to possibly make this plan self-
funded. By self-insuring this plan, and adding Stop-Loss insurance for catastrophic losses, SUN
could dramatically cut the overall cost of the plan. Employees are very satisfied with the present
Geisinger HMO, and may be reluctant to see any changes in the plans current structure.
However, with healthcare costs on the constant rise, SUN will not rule out self insurance as a
possible funding option.
Financing Considerations
One crucial aspect of SUNs employee benefit package is the fact that every benefit
offered is financed on non-contributory basis. In todays benefits world, it is strange to see a plan
that does not have at least one option partially paid by employee contributions. When asked why
SUN chooses to pay the full cost of its benefit plan, Mr. King had two reasons. First, since
employees do not have to pay any part of their premium, lower paid employees can participate in
the same level of care as higher paid employees. Secondly, non-contributory plans are much
easier to install, maintain, and prevent discriminatory issues because every employee is
automatically covered.
One problem that does arise from non-contributory financing is employees not
understanding the true cost of their benefits. Mr. King says, Since employees never see a
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
19/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 6
physical dollar amount for their plans, they have the conceptual misunderstanding that they are
free; when in reality this is obviously not the case. In order to combat this problem SUN sends
out memos to all employees alerting them of any changes to the benefit package, which includes
premium increases and the reason behind the increase. According to Mr. King, this program has
been extremely successful in educating employees on the true value of their benefits.
When asked if SUN would move away from non-contributory financing and start
requiring employees to contribute to their benefits, Mr. King responded, Yes, it is a likely
possibility. According to Mr. King, there are presently no plans to modify any of SUNs
benefits to contributory financing. However, he did state that if healthcare costs continue to rise
at their current rate, SUN will be forced to either remove certain healthcare options, or require
employees to contribute financially towards their healthcare.
Consumerism
As stated earlier, SUNs Keystone Health Plan-Central HMO is going into its last year of
being offered. To replace this plan, SUN is considering offering its employees a Consumer
Driven Healthcare Plan (CDHP) with either a Health Savings Account (HSA) or Health
Reimbursement Account (HRA). These plans are something every employer should consider
when trying to contain healthcare costs. By offering CDHPs, employees are forced to behave as
a traditional consumer, meaning they will make more reasonable decisions when it comes to
utilizing healthcare goods and services. If employees over-utilize these services, they themselves
will be held financially responsible. Although this decision is not official, and has not been
approved by SUNs Joint Operating Committee, replacing the in-network HMO with a CDHP
would be a very wise decision by SUN. Mr. King stated that if a CDHP was offered by SUN,
each employee would most likely have a Health Reimbursement Account that would be funded
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
20/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 7
by the school. The initial savings in premiums would be passed on to employees to help them
pay the high deductibles associated with these plans. As acknowledged by Mr. King, it may be
difficult for their employees to adjust to these plans, since they have grown accustom to
traditional plan designs with small copayments and low deductibles. However, CDHPs can be
beneficial for both employees and employers in combating rising healthcare costs, and are truly
the future of healthcare.
Adverse Selection
Adverse Selection should always be a concern with the design of any healthcare plan, and
SUN Area Technical Institute is no exception. By offering four different health care options,
there is a potential for SUNs health insurance risk pool to become splintered. A risk pool
becomes splintered when high risk individuals are attracted to the healthcare plan option that
offers the richest benefits, because these are the people most likely to utilize them. Conversely,
low risk individuals are attracted to the healthcare plan option that is the cheapest. In SUNs case
since all plans are financed on a non-contributory basis, this would be the option with the lowest
out-of-pocket costs (such as deductibles, copayments, and coinsurance.) This is because these
individuals know they are unlikely to utilize many healthcare goods and services, so the plan
with the cheapest overall cost for them is the one they will choose.
Obviously it seems natural that high risk individuals would be drawn towards SUNs
traditional indemnity plan. This is because although it provides little coverage for preventative
care such as check-ups and physical exams, it provides coverage (usually 80% or 100% of UCR)
for almost all hospital and surgical services at any healthcare provider. On the other hand, low
risk individuals would certainly be attracted to SUNs Geisinger in-network HMO. This is
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
21/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 8
because this plan offers the lowest out-of-pocket costs, in terms of deductibles and copayments,
of any plan offered.
In order to prevent the risk pool from splintering, we suggest that SUN considers
offering a Multiple Option plan administered by Capital BlueCross. Since two of SUNs current
health plans are already administered by Capital BlueCross, this option would not cause many
changes for the majority of SUNs employees. By offering a Multiple Option plan, every
employee would be enrolled under one contract, and then would have the choice of enrolling in
whichever option they choose; whether it be an Indemnity, PPO, or HMO. Since every employee
is covered under a single insurance contract, this is much easier administratively for SUN.
Additionally, it would allow SUN to still offer a wide variety of healthcare options, which is
what the organization prides itself on most about its current benefit package, while cutting costs
on its premium by bundling the plans together. Lastly, this option would reduce the potential
for risk pool splintering. Capital BlueCross is taking on the risks of every employee, regardless
of which option they chose. While it may pay out more claims to high risk individuals enrolled
in the richest option (indemnity), it would also be collecting premiums from the low risk
individuals enrolled in the lower options (in-network HMO). By having all employees in the
same risk pool, the low risks essentially compensate for the high risks, making the pool balanced
overall.
Regulatory Compliance
ERISA
SUN has had no problem adhering to ERISAs standards for fiduciary responsibility,
communication activities, or vesting standards. SUN complies with the fiduciary responsibility
requirement of ERISA by offering employees the choice of four different health insurance
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
22/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 9
options, and allowing them to choose whichever option is truly the best for them. Employees
have the freedom to go out-of-network with the traditional indemnity plan, but also have the cost
saving structure of staying in-network with the HMO plans. The decision to offer four different
plans was clearly made in the best interest of the employees, without attention to cost. SUN also
effectively communicates its benefit package to its employees. All employees are given an
electronic copy of the schools Summary Plan Description and Summary of Material
Modifications. As previously mentioned, SUN also sends out memos to every employee to alert
them of any changes to their benefit plan. Lastly, SUN does comply with ERISAs vesting
standards for definedbenefit plans. Any employee that began participating in the schools
defined benefit plan before July 1, 2011 follows a five-year cliff vesting schedule. While any
employee that began participating after July 1, 2011 follows a ten-year cliff vesting schedule.
COBRA
When it comes to the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA), SUN
does not see too many issues arise. SUN currently does not have any COBRA eligibles
electing continuation coverage under any of its healthcare plans. According to Mr. King, the
most common issue that SUN does face regarding COBRA is when dependent children of
employees graduate from college. SUN has chosen not to utilize a Third Party Administrator
(TPA) when it comes to compliance issues. When asked if SUN had considered outsourcing to a
TPA or why the organization chose not to, Mr. King stated that it would not be worth the
money. He explained that SUN is a relatively small employer, so while the administrative
burden is challenging when COBRA claims do occur, it would not be worth the additional cost
to outsource to a TPA with the number of employees and dependents the organization currently
covers.
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
23/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 10
HIPAA
SUN Area Technical Institute takes every step necessary to comply with the Health
Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA). Mr. King stated that keeping SUNs
employees medical information confidential is one of the schools top objectives, regardless of
the administrative burden. In regards to wellness program standards under HIPAA, Mr. King
ensures that SUNs Employee Wellness Program in no way discriminates against disabled
employees.
PPACA
SUN has already complied with certain aspects of the Patient Protection and Affordable
Care Act (PPACA). Since SUN does offer healthcare benefits to employees dependents, in
order to comply with PPACA, the age to which a dependent child can receive health insurance
benefits was raised from age 24 to age 26. In addition, although organizations are not required to
report the value of employees benefits on their Form W-2 until January 1, 2012, SUN has
chosen to plan ahead. The organization has been complying with this aspect of PPACA since the
beginning of 2011.
In regards to future compliance with PPACA, SUN has considered its options. Under
PPACA, the play or pay mandate will either require employers to continue to offer healthcare
benefits to all employees, or pay a penalty (essentially a tax) to the Federal government.
According to Mr. King, SUN has every intention of playing and continuing to offer healthcare
benefits to its employees. However, there is one potential obstacle SUN should consider. Under
PPACA, there will be an excise tax on high cost health insurance plans, known as Cadillac Plans,
which is scheduled to go into effect on January 1, 2018. This provision adds a 40% tax to any
healthcare plan that exceeds $10,200 for individuals or $27,500 for family coverage in 2018.
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
24/25
TU ID: 912-55-1427 & 912-43-4791 Page | 11
Although this tax seems logical, because the average cost of a healthcare plan today is lower than
these amounts, healthcare costs have been on a constant rise for the past few decades. At the
current rate of increase, these amounts may not be far from average six years from now, and this
could cause employers to endure thousands of dollars in excise taxes. Since SUN prides itself on
offering superior healthcare benefits, it would be wise to monitor the trend of healthcare costs,
and determine at a time closer to 2018 if playing would still in fact outweigh paying.
Conclusion
Throughout our analysis it became clear that SUN Area Technical Institute puts a greater
weight on employee satisfaction than cost when designing its employee benefit package. This is
shown through the comprehensive benefit plan that SUN offers, which contains a variety of
choices. However, if SUN were to integrate a Consumer Driven Health Plan into its benefit
offerings, it could shift some financial risk to employees, which in turn would cut costs. Also, if
SUN chooses to continue to offer the many traditional health insurance plans it currently does, it
may want to consider converting its various healthcare plans into a single Multiple Option plan.
Additionally, SUN should continue to monitor rising healthcare costs, and determine as time
goes on if the organization would still choose to play under PPACAs Play or Pay mandate.
In conclusion, SUN Area Technical Institutes benefit package effectively covers many of the
loss exposures faced by its employees, while always placing the employees interests above
anything else.
-
8/2/2019 Alexander d Schwartz - Suntechnicalinstitute.fall2011
25/25
Works Cited
Interview with:
James King
Business [email protected] East Market StreetNew Berlin, PA 17855570-966-1031 ext.112